In higher education, we often say we want students to move beyond memorization. Yet many of our exams still reward exactly that: recognize the correct answer, write it down, move to the next question.
In my own teaching, I began noticing a familiar pattern. Many students were doing well, but the lower-performing tail of the class seemed to be getting longer. These were not students who lacked potential. Many were working hard, but they were struggling to connect isolated facts into usable understanding.
That raised a simple question for me: Was my exam only measuring the gap, or could it help reduce it?
This question led me to redesign one practical exam using a format I now think of as collaborative reasoning with individual accountability. The goal was not to make the exam easier. The goal was to make students’ thinking more visible before they had to answer on their own.
The Problem With “Just Make it a Group Exam”
I did not want to simply turn the exam into a group test. That can create legitimate concerns: uneven participation, stronger students carrying weaker students, and students receiving credit for answers they may not understand.
At the same time, I did not want to ignore the value of peer discussion. Students often learn a great deal when they hear how classmates approach a problem, especially when the task requires reasoning rather than simple recall.
So the challenge became this: How do we let students benefit from discussion without removing individual accountability?
The solution was a two-phase exam station:
- Group reasoning first
- Individual answers second
Students could talk through the material, but every student still had to answer independently.
How the Format Worked
At each station, students first saw a set of tagged structures. Importantly, they did not see the questions yet.
They had a short period of time to discuss everything they knew about those structures. They could talk about identification, function, relationships, applications, or anything else that might matter.
Then the timer went off. Discussion stopped. Students flipped over the question card.
At that point, each student answered the questions individually. No talking. No group answer sheet. No shared score.
The format was simple:
- Students examine the material.
- Students discuss as a group.
- Questions are revealed.
- Students answer individually.
The group phase created the learning opportunity. The individual phase preserved accountability.
What Changed
When we compared student performance on a traditional exam with performance on the collaborative format, overall performance improved. But the more meaningful result was not the class average.
The biggest improvement came from students in the lower-performing quartiles.
That mattered to me. My goal was not to inflate grades across the board. My goal was to support the students who were struggling to make connections. The discussion seemed to give those students access to how their peers were reasoning before they had to retrieve and apply the information themselves.
The strongest students did not show the same level of improvement, likely because they were already performing near the top. But the lower tail moved, and that was the point.
What Students Thought
Student feedback was generally positive, especially around learning. Many students reported that discussion helped them understand the material more clearly and supported their individual answers.
But their feedback was not universally enthusiastic, and that is important.
Some students felt the individual answer period was too short. Others raised concerns about fairness and group dynamics. Some preferred the traditional format. Some preferred the collaborative format. Some had no strong preference.
That tension is useful. It tells us that the format has promise, but the details matter.
In future versions, I would keep the core structure but refine the timing. I would also be more explicit about expectations during the discussion phase:
- Every student should contribute.
- The goal is to explain reasoning, not just name answers.
- Discussion should focus on relationships and applications.
- Once the individual phase begins, all discussion stops.
This is not a shortcut. It is a structured thinking phase.
Why This May Work in Undergraduate Courses
Although I developed this format in an anatomy practical, the idea is not limited to anatomy or professional programs. It can work in many undergraduate courses where students need to apply concepts rather than simply recall facts.
In biology, students could examine a diagram, specimen, data figure, or microscopy image together before answering individual questions.
In chemistry, students could discuss a reaction mechanism, molecular structure, or lab scenario before individually predicting products or explaining errors.
In physics, students could reason through a diagram, graph, or conceptual problem before each student solves a related question independently.
In engineering, students could discuss a design constraint, system diagram, or failure scenario before individually explaining the next step.
In mathematics or statistics, students could discuss a problem setup, dataset, or model choice before independently completing a calculation or interpretation.
In humanities and social sciences, students could discuss a short passage, case, artifact, primary source, or policy scenario before writing an individual response.
The key is the sequence: Students discuss before seeing the questions. Then they answer individually.
That sequence matters. If students see the questions first, they may simply divide the work. If they discuss the material first, they must activate what they know more broadly. They prepare each other to think, not just to copy.
Why This Matters for Undergraduate Programs
Many undergraduate programs are concerned with persistence, DFW rates, first-generation student support, and performance gaps in gateway courses. Often, the students who struggle most are not unwilling to learn; they may simply lack access to the reasoning strategies that more experienced or confident students are already using.
This format gives them a brief window into those strategies.
They hear how peers identify key features, eliminate wrong ideas, connect concepts, and decide what matters. Then they must answer on their own.
That is the balance I find valuable: support without removing responsibility.
Practical Tips for Trying This Yourself
Faculty do not need to redesign an entire course to try this approach. Start small.
Use it for one quiz, one exam section, one lab practical, or a few problem-solving stations.
I would recommend:
- Keep groups small: three to five students.
- Hide the questions during the discussion phase.
- Use a visible timer.
- Keep individual answers short.
- Use mostly foundational questions with a few deeper application questions.
- Avoid group scores.
- Collect feedback immediately afterward.
- Tell students why you are using the format.
The last point matters. Students may assume group work means the exam will be easier. I tell them directly: this is not designed to make the exam easier. It is designed to make the thinking more visible.
Final Thought
Assessment does not have to be separate from learning. With careful design, it can become part of the learning process itself.
The lesson for me was not that every exam should become collaborative. They should not. The lesson was more practical: when students are allowed to reason together before answering individually, struggling students may get the support they need without removing accountability.
That is the kind of assessment worth building.
Dr. Pradeep Malreddy is a Clinical Associate Professor at Kansas State University, specializing in Anatomy and Histology. Holding a DVM from India and an MS from Kansas State, he brings a blend of clinical and academic expertise. He has additional certifications in Medical Education Research and Online Teaching from AAMC and Harvard. Dr. Malreddy has developed a One-Year Master’s Program at K-State and teaches courses in anatomy, histology, and physiology. His research focuses on anatomy education, eye-tracking technology, and active learning. An active member of professional organizations like the American Association of Veterinary Anatomists, he has received accolades for teaching excellence and diversity initiatives. He was recently honored with Fellowship in the United Kingdom’s prestigious Academy of Medical Educators.


